News Summary
Ilya Shapiro’s planned speech at NYU’s law school has been canceled due to security issues coinciding with the anniversary of a terrorist attack. The decision raises concerns about free speech and selective disfavoring of speakers. Shapiro criticized the cancellation, highlighting the challenges faced by conservative voices in academic environments amidst ongoing debates over cancel culture.
New York City – The speech by legal scholar Ilya Shapiro at New York University’s law school, scheduled for October 7, has been canceled due to security concerns. Shapiro intended to discuss his book “Lawless: The Miseducation of American Elites,” which examines incidents of cancel culture within American law schools, including his personal experiences. This event coincided with a sensitive date, marking the two-year anniversary of a terrorist attack by Hamas on Israeli citizens.
NYU law school authorities expressed that the security situation for the week was strained, which directly influenced their decision to cancel Shapiro’s speech. After discussions among the organizers from the Federalist Society, who initially aimed to relocate the event for security purposes, it became clear that changing the event date was not feasible due to Shapiro’s scheduling constraints. Penelope Fernandes, an administrator, had previously agreed to the event but later communicated its cancellation to students.
Associate Dean Megan McDermott confirmed that security resources were already allocated to prior events, leading to the conclusion that hosting Shapiro’s speech was not manageable under the current circumstances. Despite the cancellation of Shapiro’s talk, the Federalist Society was allowed to host a separate event during the same week, raising questions about possible selective disfavor towards certain speakers.
Shapiro criticized the cancellation, suggesting that it illustrated a failure of university leadership in addressing free speech. He offered to send a copy of his book to the dean of NYU in a bid to highlight the issues he discusses in it. In a subsequent clarification, NYU administration stated that they did not outright cancel the event, suggesting that the circumstances were miscommunicated.
Free speech advocates have condemned the decision, labeling it as a “textbook heckler’s veto.” They argue that universities must maintain a consistent approach to speaker approvals and not selectively disfavor certain individuals while permitting others. This situation reflects a broader, evolving political landscape surrounding free speech at universities, particularly concerning conservative voices who are now facing similar challenges to those formerly encountered primarily by liberal individuals and groups.
Shapiro’s history with cancel culture is notable; he previously resigned from a planned role at Georgetown University after facing backlash over a social media post regarding President Biden’s Supreme Court nominee. His comments, which critiqued affirmative action and addressed racial identity in judicial appointments, generated significant controversy and criticism at the time.
This incident at NYU adds to the ongoing dialogue about free speech on college campuses, particularly relating to how institutions navigate the complexities of fostering open discourse while addressing security concerns and maintaining a diverse range of viewpoints. As academic institutions grapple with these multifaceted challenges, the reactions to Shapiro’s canceled speech serve as a case study on the implications of cancel culture and the protection of free expression in a polarized environment.
Deeper Dive: News & Info About This Topic
HERE Resources
Additional Resources
- The College Fix: NYU Law School Cancels Speech About Cancel Culture
- Deseret News: RIP Cancel Culture
- New York Post: NYU College Republican President Ousted
- Washington Post: Hamas, Israel, and Cancel Culture
- Wikipedia: Cancel Culture
Author: STAFF HERE BALTIMORE WRITER
BALTIMORE STAFF WRITER The BALTIMORE STAFF WRITER represents the experienced team at HEREBaltimore.com, your go-to source for actionable local news and information in Baltimore, Baltimore County, and beyond. Specializing in "news you can use," we cover essential topics like product reviews for personal and business needs, local business directories, politics, real estate trends, neighborhood insights, and state news affecting the area—with deep expertise drawn from years of dedicated reporting and strong community input, including local press releases and business updates. We deliver top reporting on high-value events such as the Baltimore Book Festival, Preakness Stakes, and Artscape. Our coverage extends to key organizations like the Baltimore Chamber of Commerce and Visit Baltimore, plus leading businesses in shipping and healthcare that power the local economy such as the Port of Baltimore and Johns Hopkins Medicine. As part of the broader HERE network, we provide comprehensive, credible insights into Maryland's dynamic landscape.
